It was meant to be the week Jacinta Allan took a firm stance on the “crime crisis”, but it could instead mark the beginning of the end for her government.
It began on Monday with the Victorian premier announcing a new police taskforce, Operation Hawk, which appeared, on the surface, a decisive move to combat corruption on government construction sites.
Within hours, it was revealed that the taskforce had already been operating for nine months.
On Tuesday, Allan refused to say whether she had misled the public or was misled by Victoria police, instead stating she had been relying on the information provided to her by the new police commissioner.
The pressure only intensified on Wednesday, when Allan was forced to fend off accusations of corruption and misconduct made by a former senior police officer.
Then, on Thursday, came the release of the latest crime statistics data, showing a 13.2% increase in the state’s crime rate – the highest since 2016. Offences committed by children aged between 10 and 17 rose to their highest levels since electronic records began in 1993.
The Coalition was quick to seize on the data, with opposition leader, Brad Battin, accusing the government of failing to keep Victorians safe.
“The numbers don’t lie – Labor has lost control of law and order and Victorians are paying the price,” he said.
On this front, at least, the government appeared prepared. Earlier in the week, it had introduced changes to the Bail Act to parliament, claiming they would help reduce offending (though they have been widely criticised by legal, human rights and First Nations groups – and even privately by some within Labor’s ranks).
The premier and several of her MPs took to social media to promote the so-called “Tough Bail Bill”, mirroring the media release announcing the bill, which used the word “tough” or “toughest” 33 times.
Kos Samaras, a former Labor strategist and RedBridge director, has criticised the party’s “newfound love for being tough on crime”, comparing it to a “long political suicide note”.
He says this isn’t the first time the Victorian Labor party has found itself facing a “crime crisis” – in 2016, when crime rates were similarly high and concern over the Apex gang hit overdrive, the opposition ramped up its attacks on law and order.
In the lead-up to the 2018 election, Liberal MPs pushed a narrative centred on “African gangs”, including Peter Dutton’s now-infamous comments about Melburnians being afraid to go out for dinner.
The then premier, Daniel Andrews, didn’t take the bait, and it proved to be a winning move for Labor.
Crime, defence, and immigration are traditional strengths for the Coalition, and Samaras says Labor should remember that: “Once you move onto your opponents’ turf, you’re going to lose”.
after newsletter promotion
Instead, Labor’s success in 2018 came from a focus on its core issues of education, health, jobs and public transport. Federal Labor has emulated this, as it focuses on Medicare in the lead up to the May election.
Perhaps the path forward for Victorian Labor can be found in data that went largely overlooked on Thursday: the huge increase in theft of groceries, clothing and alcohol linked to adult offenders, often in their 30s, facing cost of living pressures.
The issue is the primary concern of voters, who have been crying out for bold ideas to ease the pressure. All Allan has offered them is $400 vouchers for school children and daily reporting on fuel prices.
Instead, she’s become known for backflips – from bail and raising the age of criminal responsibility, to ignoring recommendations for a second injecting room and a ban on duck hunting. The one issue on which the premier has expressed a bold, progressive vision on is housing. In October, she vowed to make Victoria the “townhouse capital” of Australia as part of a bid to help millennials own homes. It will take years, though, before any results are seen.
A Labor insider said tackling cost of living would also work to reduce crime.
“Young people don’t just commit crimes – it’s a result of systemic, class-based disadvantage which cannot be ignored,” they said.
“It’s very sad to see a supposedly centre left government focus on imprisonment and not the social and economic determinants of youth crime.”
There’s a lesson in this week for the Liberals too. While Battin, a former police officer, is comfortable talking tough on crime, after the 2018 loss, an internal review was scathing of the party’s law and order strategy.
According to the review, it was seen as a political tactic rather than a genuine plan to improve public safety – and only influenced 6% of voters and not necessarily in the Coalition’s favour.
The opposition needs more than just a focus on crime to win government and it needs unity, which already began to fray as it was revealed on Tuesday Battin went on a four-day cruise last week as debate over crime reached fever pitch.
In the early hours of Friday morning, Labor’s bail bill passed parliament. But the word “tough” was missing from its title, after the opposition moved an amendment to scrap it, arguing it wasn’t tough enough.
While seemingly petty, the move underscores the reality for Allan: no matter what Labor does on law and order, the opposition is always prepared to go further.
It’s a political battle Labor simply can’t win.